
Watch the ref
Nobody has added this meme's ref yet. Got the original video or post?
In MyMemeCards, the meme card game, “After All, Why Not? Why Shouldn't I Keep It?” is a rare card of the Memes World series 12, number 3567 of the collection, and the 136th best-known meme of its 295 cards. Here is what the meme means, where it comes from, and how to get its card.
What does the “After All, Why Not? Why Shouldn't I Keep It?” meme mean?
This meme captures the guilty pleasure of retaining borrowed objects indefinitely. It highlights the internal monologue where a temporary loan becomes permanent possession. Users relate to Bilbo's rationalization to excuse their own minor selfishness, turning a moral lapse into a funny, relatable confession.
Where does the “After All, Why Not? Why Shouldn't I Keep It?” meme come from?
The line originates from The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, released on December 19th, 2001. In the scene, Bilbo Baggins (Ian Holm) hesitates to give the One Ring to Frodo. Before handing it to Gandalf, he asks, "After all, why not? Why shouldn't I keep it?". The meme format emerged around 2013. On December 16th, 2013, YouTuber Brian Herman uploaded the clip. By May 15th, 2014, Imgur user David43 created a three-panel version about a borrowed pen. On April 24th, 2018, Redditor Teegi adapted it for Reddit upvotes. On May 5th, 2019, Twitter user @isawken used it as a reaction image for a child keeping a rock.
- 2001Release of the film and the creation of the original quote by the screenwriters.
- 2013Viral upload of the raw scene on YouTube by Brian Herman.
- 2014Appearance of the image macro format on Imgur with textual adaptation.
How to use the “After All, Why Not? Why Shouldn't I Keep It?” meme
- Share a picture of a library book you forgot to return with this caption.
- React to a friend who keeps borrowing your clothes using this image.
- Post a photo of a cool rock you found and decided to take home.
Also searched as
- Why Shouldn't I Keep It?
- Bilbo keeping the ring
- After all why not image macro
- after all why not meme
- bilbo baggins why shouldnt i keep it
- lotr meme borrowed items
- after all why not meaning
The “After All, Why Not? Why Shouldn't I Keep It?” card in MyMemeCards
| Number | No. 3567 |
|---|---|
| Rarity | Rare |
| Collection | Memes World series 12 |
| Fame | 69/100 · #136 of 295 |
| Recycle value | 10 MemeCoins (30 in Shiny) |
| Meme page views | 98,912 |
How to get the “After All, Why Not? Why Shouldn't I Keep It?” card
Every pack holds 5 meme cards, the first 3 of them Common; After All, Why Not? Why Shouldn't I Keep It? comes out of the Memes World series 12 as a rare card. The pack odds say what each rarity weighs.
Your first pack is free and needs no account. After that a new free pack lands every 10 minutes, up to 3 waiting for you. You can also buy the card with MemeCoins on the market, bid for it at auction, or trade it — and a double recycles into 10 MemeCoins.
Open your free pack
5 meme cards, one of them at least Rare. One free pack per person.
Free · no account needed
Odds per card, averaged over a pack: Common 72%, Rare 23.9%, Epic 3.2%, Legendary 0.56%, Mythic 0.3%, Full Art ≤ 0.1%, Shiny 0.2%. Cards 1 to 3 are always Common, cards 4 and 5 climb the rarities. Rates drop for cards that circulate a lot. Details
Memes like “After All, Why Not? Why Shouldn't I Keep It?”
More cards of the Memes World series 12
Frequently asked questions
What does after all why not meme mean?
It refers to a quote from Bilbo Baggins used to justify keeping borrowed items forever.
Who says after all why not lotr?
Bilbo Baggins, played by Ian Holm, says this line in the first movie.
After all why not origin?
The phrase comes from The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring released in 2001.
How do I get the After All, Why Not? Why Shouldn't I Keep It? meme card?
Open a pack of MyMemeCards: “After All, Why Not? Why Shouldn't I Keep It?” is a rare card of the Memes World series 12. Your first pack is free, with no account, and you can also buy, trade or win the card at auction.
How rare is the After All, Why Not? Why Shouldn't I Keep It? card?
It is a Rare card. Rarity decides which pack slot can deal it, and what it is worth on the market.
Sources: Know Your Meme · checked on October 2, 2026.
Read next
Want After All, Why Not? Why Shouldn't I Keep It? in your collection?
Open your free pack: 5 meme cards, no account needed.