Play

“Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That” meme: meaning, origin and rare card

The "Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That" meme is an ironic image macro from a 2011 interview.

MyMemeCards editorial teamPublished 12 min read
Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That meme
The “Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That” meme, 2011

Watch the ref

Nobody has added this meme's ref yet. Got the original video or post?

In MyMemeCards, the meme card game, “Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That” is a rare card of the Classics pack, number 101 of the collection, and the 100th best-known meme of its 300 cards. Here is what the meme means, where it comes from, and how to get its card.

What does the “Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That” meme mean?

This visual expresses mocking skepticism toward theological arguments based on simple wonder. It highlights the perceived absurdity when a public figure refuses to accept rational scientific explanations for daily events like tides. The dominant emotion is intellectual disdain: people laugh at dogmatic rigidity collapsing before elementary logic, reminding viewers that some mysteries are simply understood physical mechanisms.

Where does the “Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That” meme come from?

The origin traces back to January 4, 2011, during an episode of The O'Reilly Factor on Fox News. Bill O'Reilly interviewed Dave Silverman, president of Atheists United, regarding an advertisement claiming religion was a scam. When Silverman demanded proof of God's existence, O'Reilly argued he knew God because tides came in and out regularly without fail and could not be explained without supernatural intervention. Silverman's facial reaction, mixing disbelief and amusement, inspired the "Are You Serious?" rage face. The first macro featuring the quote was posted to Reddit on February 9, 2011, receiving nearly ten thousand upvotes. A dedicated subreddit was created the same day. The format spread rapidly via Memegenerator and Quickmeme, before being picked up by Geekosystem, Urlesque, Funny or Die, Buzzfeed, and AcidCow throughout February 2011.

  1. January 2011Broadcast of the controversial Fox News interview involving Bill O'Reilly and Dave Silverman.
  2. February 9, 2011Publication of the first image macro on Reddit with the iconic quote.
  3. February 2011Creation of the dedicated subreddit and massive propagation across several online humor platforms.

How to use the “Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That” meme

  • Use this meme to mock a pseudoscientific or magical explanation given for an established fact.
  • Reply to someone invoking chance or destiny to justify a mundane natural phenomenon.
  • Illustrate the contrast between rigid belief and simple, observable physical reality.

Also searched as

  • Are You Serious? face
  • Knowledgeable Neil meme
  • Actually Stephen I can explain that
  • bill o'reilly you can't explain that meaning
  • bill o'reilly tides god argument
  • dave silverman atheist billboard origin
  • bill o'reilly factor january 4 2011
  • you can't explain that meme origin
  • neil degrasse tyson explain that meme
  • are you serious rage face origin

The “Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That” card in MyMemeCards

Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That card
NumberNo. 101
RarityRare
CollectionClassics pack
Fame81/100 · #100 of 300
Recycle value10 MemeCoins (30 in Shiny)
Meme page views732,160
Rarities of the Classics pack: 300 cards
  • Common13344%
  • Rare8528%
  • Epic4314%
  • Legendary144.7%
  • Mythic155.0%
  • Full Art103.3%
Views of the meme's reference page: 2.5× the collection's median
  • Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That732,160
  • Median292,605
  • Navy Seal Copypasta16,405,213

How to get the “Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That” card

Every pack holds 5 meme cards, the first 3 of them Common; Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That comes out of the Classics pack as a rare card. The pack odds say what each rarity weighs.

Your first pack is free and needs no account. After that a new free pack lands every 10 minutes, up to 3 waiting for you. You can also buy the card with MemeCoins on the market, bid for it at auction, or trade it — and a double recycles into 10 MemeCoins.

Open your free pack

5 meme cards, one of them at least Rare. One free pack per person.

Free · no account needed

Odds per card, averaged over a pack: Common 72%, Rare 23.9%, Epic 3.2%, Legendary 0.56%, Mythic 0.3%, Full Art ≤ 0.1%, Shiny 0.2%. Cards 1 to 3 are always Common, cards 4 and 5 climb the rarities. Rates drop for cards that circulate a lot. Details

Memes like “Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That”

More cards of the Classics pack

Every card of the Classics pack →

Frequently asked questions

Bill O'Reilly you can't explain that meaning?

This phrase mocks the inability to rationally explain a natural phenomenon. It highlights the fallacious argument of attributing a known physical process to divine intervention due to a lack of scientific understanding.

Dave Silverman Atheists billboard?

Dave Silverman, president of Atheists United, launched an ad campaign claiming religion is a scam. This triggered the televised confrontation with Bill O'Reilly, the direct source of the meme.

Bill O'Reilly tides explanation?

O'Reilly claimed tides prove God because they work perfectly without human explanation. This assertion was criticized for ignoring known gravitational laws, generating the disbelief captured in the meme.

Neil deGrasse Tyson actually I can explain that?

Stephen Colbert invited Neil deGrasse Tyson to refute O'Reilly. Tyson stated he could explain the tides, creating a meme variant where the scientific expert reassures the skeptical host.

How do I get the Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That meme card?

Open a pack of MyMemeCards: “Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That” is a rare card of the Classics pack. Your first pack is free, with no account, and you can also buy, trade or win the card at auction.

How rare is the Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That card?

It is a Rare card. Rarity decides which pack slot can deal it, and what it is worth on the market.

Sources: Know Your Meme · checked on October 2, 2026.

Read next

Want Bill O'Reilly You Can't Explain That in your collection?

Open your free pack: 5 meme cards, no account needed.

Open your free pack