Play

“Motte and Bailey Fallacy” meme: meaning, origin and common card

The "Motte and Bailey" is a logical fallacy where one defends a controversial claim first, then retreats to a modest, easily defensible position when challenged, creating the illusion that the original controversial point was upheld.

MyMemeCards editorial teamPublished 9 min read
Motte and Bailey Fallacy meme
The “Motte and Bailey Fallacy” meme, 2019

Watch the ref

Nobody has added this meme's ref yet. Got the original video or post?

In MyMemeCards, the meme card game, “Motte and Bailey Fallacy” is a common card of the Memes World series 62, number 18531 of the collection, and the 29th best-known meme of its 296 cards. Here is what the meme means, where it comes from, and how to get its card.

What does the “Motte and Bailey Fallacy” meme mean?

This meme visualizes a rhetorical maneuver. The speaker initially advances an ambitious, controversial thesis (the bailey). When confronted with criticism or evidence, instead of abandoning it, they retreat to a trivial, undeniable statement (the motte). This safe haven is easy to defend. The tactic creates the appearance that the original bold claim has been validated, while it has actually been replaced by a much weaker, less disputable proposition.

Where does the “Motte and Bailey Fallacy” meme come from?

The term originates from medieval castle architecture, featuring a fortified tower (motte) and an enclosed courtyard (bailey). Defenders would retreat to the secure tower during attacks. Philosopher Nicholas Shackel conceptualized this as an argumentative strategy in his 2005 paper "The Vacuity of Postmodernist Methodology." He described how proponents of controversial views hide behind simple truths when challenged. The meme format went viral on February 26th, 2019, when Twitter user @Noahpinion posted an image macro template of a castle with captions explaining the concept and providing an example, sparking widespread adoption.

  1. 2005Philosopher Nicholas Shackel publishes his paper defining the logical fallacy using the castle analogy.
  2. February 26, 2019Twitter user @Noahpinion shares the first explorable graphical template with a clear educational explanation.

How to use the “Motte and Bailey Fallacy” meme

  • Use the format to criticize politicians who soften their extreme statements after public backlash.
  • Apply the image to highlight scientists who narrow their conclusions significantly after peer review criticism.
  • Post a variant to illustrate online debates where users shift from strong assertions to vague platitudes.

Also searched as

  • Motte-and-Bailey Argument
  • Castle defense analogy
  • Retreat to the motte
  • motte and bailey fallacy meaning
  • motte and bailey meme explanation
  • who coined motte and bailey
  • noahpinion motte and bailey tweet

The “Motte and Bailey Fallacy” card in MyMemeCards

Motte and Bailey Fallacy card
NumberNo. 18531
RarityCommon
CollectionMemes World series 62
Fame48/100 · #29 of 296
Recycle value5 MemeCoins (15 in Shiny)
Meme page views2,938
Rarities of the Memes World series 62: 296 cards
  • Common296100%
Views of the meme's reference page: close to the collection's median
  • Motte and Bailey Fallacy2,938
  • Median3,020
  • Pump and Dump3,194

How to get the “Motte and Bailey Fallacy” card

Every pack holds 5 meme cards, the first 3 of them Common; Motte and Bailey Fallacy comes out of the Memes World series 62 as a common card. The pack odds say what each rarity weighs.

Your first pack is free and needs no account. After that a new free pack lands every 10 minutes, up to 3 waiting for you. You can also buy the card with MemeCoins on the market, bid for it at auction, or trade it — and a double recycles into 5 MemeCoins.

Open your free pack

5 meme cards, one of them at least Rare. One free pack per person.

Free · no account needed

Odds per card, averaged over a pack: Common 72%, Rare 23.9%, Epic 3.2%, Legendary 0.56%, Mythic 0.3%, Full Art ≤ 0.1%, Shiny 0.2%. Cards 1 to 3 are always Common, cards 4 and 5 climb the rarities. Rates drop for cards that circulate a lot. Details

Memes like “Motte and Bailey Fallacy”

More cards of the Memes World series 62

Every card of the Memes World series 62 →

Frequently asked questions

What does motte and bailey mean?

It refers to an argumentative strategy where one defends a controversial idea first, then retreats to a modest, indisputable position to avoid contradiction while appearing victorious.

Who is nicholas shackel?

He is a philosopher who introduced the term in 2005 to describe a reasoning method used in certain postmodern texts considered devoid of meaning.

Motte and bailey meme origin?

The viral visual format was created and shared by Twitter user @Noahpinion on February 26, 2019, directly inspired by the 2005 philosophical theory.

How do I get the Motte and Bailey Fallacy meme card?

Open a pack of MyMemeCards: “Motte and Bailey Fallacy” is a common card of the Memes World series 62. Your first pack is free, with no account, and you can also buy, trade or win the card at auction.

How rare is the Motte and Bailey Fallacy card?

It is a Common card. Rarity decides which pack slot can deal it, and what it is worth on the market.

Sources: Know Your Meme · checked on October 2, 2026.

Read next

Want Motte and Bailey Fallacy in your collection?

Open your free pack: 5 meme cards, no account needed.

Open your free pack